Why Perfectionism Can Feel Safer Than Stillness | EMDR Therapy in Phoenix

Perfectionism can look like strength on the outside, but inside it leaves you exhausted and stuck.

Photo by Vasilis Caravitis on Unsplash

Peace sounds nice… in theory. But for many EMDR Therapy clients I work in Phoenix, it can feel absolutely terrifying. Stillness leaves space. Space that grates on your skin and is somehow way too loud with its silence.

Perfectionism, on the other hand, feels familiar. Maybe not safe or good, but familiar. Even if it leaves you feeling like shit by the end of the day — burned out, on edge, or in a downward spiral after a single misstep — at least it feels predictable and under your control.

But damn, is it exhausting. And deep down, you secretly dream of something more.

Why Perfectionism Feels Safe

Some clients I’ve worked with have been surprised to realize their perfectionism actually began as a survival skill — something that helped them feel safe and in control.

And if we think about it, this often makes sense.

I think about the little girl hiding in her closet, trying to block out the too-loud voices. In those moments, being perfect helps avoid drawing attention and keeps harsh words at bay, at least for that moment.

I think about the highly anxious overachiever in the sixth work meeting of the day, furiously scribbling notes while keeping tabs on their never-ending to-do list — and still volunteering for yet another obligation they know they don’t have time for.

The nervous system craves predictability, even if it’s painful.

All of these examples show people who learned early on that by being perfect, by over-volunteering, or by conforming to exactly what someone else wanted, they could avoid criticism, harsh words, or worse.

So even if perfectionism and anxiety no longer serve the same function in adulthood, they still bring a sense of safety and predictability. And if nothing else, our nervous systems crave that.

Over time, this survival skill creates themes and beliefs that twist in our guts and feel like unshakable truths:

On the surface you may look like you have it all together, but inside perfectionism and anxiety are exhausting you

Photo by Vasilis Caravitis on Unsplash

• “If I do everything right, maybe I’ll finally be loved — or at least avoid criticism.”

• “I’m worthless if I can’t do this.”

Those voices become second nature. They create an evolving narrative that tells us we have to perform, perfectly, to be accepted. And if people have come to expect that from us? We keep going — because it’s what we know.

The Hidden Cost of Perfectionism

This cycle of striving and performing shows up in jobs, families, and relationships. On the surface, it often appears to be a success.

But below the surface? We’re depleted. Exhausted. On the edge of burnout. And above all — lonely.

At our core, we crave being truly known and cared for by someone else. But to let that happen would mean being vulnerable. It would mean letting the mask of perfection slip. And that feels terrifying.

The problem is: even though the mask keeps us safe, it also keeps us isolated.

If we keep the mask on, keep up the pretenses, and the endless to-do list, everyone else stays at arm’s length. We might be the shoulder everyone else cries on, but no one ever gets close enough to really see us.

That acceptance we do receive is conditional — based on what we do and how well we perform. So the cycle of perfection must continue to keep up the illusion of safety. But it also leaves us profoundly alone.

The Moment When Perfectionism Stops Working and How EMDR Therapy in Phoenix Can Help

Perfectionism can feel like wearing a mask — it hides your pain, but it also keeps you isolated.

Photo by John Noonan on Unsplash

Typically, this is the point when someone picks up their phone, starts Googling, and stumbles across EMDR therapy in Phoenix or Tempe.

It’s the moment when everything has become too much — a panic attack, total burnout, or the feeling of drowning in an ever-building cycle.

By the time people call me, they’re often caught between two powerful forces: fear and curiosity.

They’re terrified — terrified of opening up to a stranger, terrified this will be yet another thing that doesn’t work. And yet, they’re so f*cking tired of living this way. Their nervous systems are fried. They’re desperate for a breath of air.

And beneath all that fear? There’s an undercurrent of hope: “What if this actually works? What if I could finally feel better?”

Making Peace Feel Safe Again

Here’s the uncomfortable truth: healing isn’t linear. It’s messy. It’s a leap forward, a step sideways, maybe even a step back — before another two or three steps forward again.

It doesn’t happen overnight (though I wish it did). And it can be frustrating, because the beliefs we’re trying to undo have been there a long time.

But here’s what I know — both as a therapist and as someone who’s sat in the client chair: movement is possible.

If you can trust the process and find a therapist you click with, layers of shame, fear, and anxiety start to shift. They get replaced with tools to regulate your body during the week. Old, rigid beliefs soften. And for the first time, peace can begin to feel less like danger — and more like a possibility.

Perfectionism is like continuing to wear armor that once kept you safe, but now weighs you down. EMDR therapy can help you loosen that grip so moving forward feels less terrifying and more freeing.

How EMDR Therapy in Phoenix Helps Ease Perfectionism

No matter the therapy modality, healing will feel uncomfortable at first. It’s unfamiliar — and your nervous system will protest.

That’s why it’s so important to find a professional who will really listen and create a space where you feel safe. EMDR therapy in Phoenix and Tempe can help you:

• Reprocess the root experiences that made perfectionism feel like your only option.

• Release the belief that you must perform to be safe or lovable.

• Learn to regulate your nervous system in new, gentler ways.

Peace doesn’t come in a giant leap. It comes in small, steady steps — allowing you to be present in your body and connected to people who truly see you.

You deserve it.

Kandace Ledergerber, LPC/LMHC EMDR Therapy Phoenix - You are already enough — even if perfectionism has tried to convince you otherwise.

If perfectionism feels like the only option but is leaving you drained, EMDR therapy in Phoenix and Tempe might be the first step in helping you feel safe in stillness.

I invite you to reach out for a complimentary consultation, where we can talk about what’s been weighing you down and explore whether I might be the right fit for your needs.

You deserve a space where you can finally lay down the heavy load of perfectionism you’ve been carrying.

TL;DR

Perfectionism often starts as a survival skill — a way to stay safe and avoid criticism. But over time, it becomes exhausting, isolating, and leaves you burned out and lonely. Stillness feels unsafe at first, but with EMDR therapy in Phoenix and Tempe, you can begin to release the armor of perfectionism and learn to feel safe in peace.

You don’t have to keep performing to be loved. Healing is possible, and you deserve it.